Islam Under Scrutiny by Ex-Muslims

Out of Concept

Scene - 1

(Place - Mecca, Time - Beginning of Islam) 

Lights, Camera, Action-- 

Quraish chief: Oh son of Abdullah, why are you insulting our gods? 

Mohammad: Allah is my friend, Oh idol worshippers! I obey none but Allah. 

Quraish chief: We will give you whichever woman you want and we will give you dozens of she-camels that you may use as you wish, if only you will no longer speak ill of our gods. And we even have another proposal for you. 

Mohammad: Oh infidels, what is this other option, if I may ask?

Quraish chief: If you worship our gods for a year, we will worship your god for the same amount of time. 

Mohammad: Hold on, Kafirs! Let me check with my lord before I decide rashly!

Quraish chief: Oh Mohammad! Feel free to chat with your fantasy friend but we offered the best that you may ever know!

Mohammad: Eureka! Eureka! My lord has just spoken to me, and he commanded: "Unto you your religion, and unto me my religion." (Q 109.006)

While watching the filming of the great prophet Mohammad's life, I well up with emotion and must dry the tears from my eyes. What a benevolent statement! What a generous person he was! Our beloved prophet understood the importance of the freedom to practice one's own religion. Allah was so merciful and compassionate at the early age of Islam! The followers of Islam used to pray facing Jerusalem and the tribe of Quraish had the Kaba, a perfect example of religious tolerance.

Scene - 2

(Place - Mecca, Time - Before migrating to Medina)

Lights, Camera, Action, --.

1st companion: Boss, we have a problem.

Mohammad: Now what?

1st companion: People are talking about Allah's flip-flops. Some of his revelations are contradicting previous revelations.

Mohammad: Oh I forgot to tell you, Allah's secretary Gabriel just visited me. Allah is aware of this situation and has sent a memorandum in this regard. He commented, "When we substitute one revelation for another, - and Allah knows best what He reveals (in stages), - they say, "Thou art but a forger": but most of them understand not." (Q 16.101)

So, Allah cannot see the future. He changes his mind as the prophet gets into different situations. Hmm... interesting. But now I' m losing faith in this Mohammad guy and his friend Allah. How can I trust a god who doesn't know what he's doing? Allah is claiming that he knows best but at the same time he is replacing his own word with new ones just because the situations have changed.

Scene - 3

(Place - Medina, Time - after migrating from Mecca to Medina)


Mohammad: I am having a bad hair day. I am frustrated and angry.

1st companion: Oh prophet, have we done anything wrong?

Mohammad:  I am not angry with you fellows, I'm teed off by those stubborn, pesky, confounding Jews.

2nd companion: Allow me to go out, kill a Jew and deliver you his beautiful wife.

Mohammad: Idiot, did I ask for another woman? I have plenty of those. I'm upset because we've been praying towards the temple of Jerusalem and it was expected that those accursed Jews would accept our religion. Looks like this strategy is not working, they refuse to convert. 

1st companion: We can always change our direction to the Kaaba of Mecca, after all that's where we used to live. 

2nd companion: But won't the people call us fools if we move Allah from one house to another?

Mohammad: Bingo! That's a good idea! Wait, Wait! I hear a phone ringing in my head, maybe it's a revelation. Yes, indeed it is a revelation. Allah just commanded, "The fools among the people will say: "What hath turned them from the Qibla to which they were used?" Say: To Allah belong both east and West: He guideth whom He will to a Way that is straight." (Q 002.142)

I'm confused. Why made Allah change his home from Jerusalem to Mecca, a move that would only open the door to a confrontation with the Quraish? Moudidi, a famous scholar of Islam clearly explained,

"In this portion, the declaration of the change of qiblah from the Temple (Jerusalem) to the Ka`abah (Makkah) was made as a symbol of the change of leadership from the children of Israel to the Muslim Community,-"

What's wrong with this prophet guy? I'm downright disgusted with his deceptive modus operandi. Allah never claimed that he had a vacation home in Mecca. After gaining a foothold in Medina, Mohammad decided to pray towards Mecca, knowing that the house of Kaba was still full of idols. So, did the Muslims (along with Mohammad) worship many idols until he conquered Mecca? 

Scene - 4

(Place - Medina, Time - End of Medina stage, preparing to re-capture Mecca)

Lights, Camera, Action-..

Ali: Oh father-in-law, command me before I leave for Mecca.

Mohammad: I am proud of you Ali. I love you so much, I gave you my daughter as well as many slave women to enjoy. You are the sword of Islam.

Ali: Oh Prophet, you are my hero. I believe Abu Bakr has already reached Mecca. Is there any message that I must relay to him?

Mohammad: Yes, I have received some new revelations regarding the Mushriks, the idol worshippers.

Ali: Sing along, Oh Prophet sing along.

Mohammad: "And an announcement from Allah and His Messenger, to the people (assembled) on the day of the Great Pilgrimage,- that Allah and His Messenger dissolve (treaty) obligations with the Pagans. If then, ye repent, it were best for you; but if ye turn away, know ye that ye cannot frustrate Allah. And proclaim a grievous penalty to those who reject Faith. (Q 009.003)

Ali: I am impressed, I will be happy to fulfill Allah's command.

Mohammad: Allah also told me, "Then, when the sacred months have passed, slay the idolaters wherever ye find them, and take them (captive), and besiege them, and prepare for them each ambush.-" (Q 009.005)

Is this the same guy who chanted, "Unto you your religion, and unto me my religion?" Now the prophet and Allah have decided to punish those who would refuse to wave the Islamic flag. Apparently, the theory of religious tolerance was replaced with blackmail and aggression - the true colors of Islam being practiced today.

Though a few personal considerations have been slapped in, the four scenarios shown above are based on historical events as recounted by the Quran and Ahadith. Those chronologically correct reenactments clearly show how power and greed transformed a prophet into a beast. Towards the end of his career, Mohammad stopped walking and talking like a prophet and became the perfect role model for all future pirates and dictators. He didn't stoop to bad faith, duplicity and violence, he raised such iniquities to the level of religious virtue.

Verses 9.3 and 9.5, mentioned in the last scene, impart direct orders to treat non-Muslims harshly. In point of fact, all the verses of this surah AL-TAWBA are full of senseless hostility and cruelty. Muslims often downplay these verses claiming that they were intended for wartime and therefore should not apply to daily life. Interestingly, there was no war at that time. In fact, those verses were plucked out of thin air right after the treaty of Hudaibiyah, which, as soon as Mohammad became strong enough, was conveniently voided by Allah. 

Moududi proudly explains, "The first discourse (1-37), was revealed in Zil-Qa'adah A. H. 9 or thereabout. As the importance of the subject of the discourse required its declaration on the occasion of Hajj the Holy Prophet dispatched Hadrat Ali to follow Hadrat Abu Bakr, who had already left for Makkah as leader of the Pilgrims to the Ka'abah. He instructed Hadrat Ali to deliver the discourse before the representatives of the different clans of Arabia so as to inform them of the new policy towards the mushriks."

Aha! A new policy towards the non-believers! Aren't our holier-than-thou Jihadi butt-kicking brothers following the latest rule of Mohammad?

Logically, a decision taken at a later time overrules the previous one and the verdicts of a high court take precedence over the lower courts. Someone can be a very honest person all his life, but if he commits a crime at the end of his life, he will be judged in accordance to his present deed. Likewise, the final commandants of the Quran surpass previous verses. There are no ands, ifs or buts... that's the plain fact of the matter and that's how devoted Muslims' minds work. 

Muslim apologists often bring an 'out-of-context' excuse from their magical bag of lies, but they don't realize that they simply are out-of-concept! Nowhere in the Quran is it mentioned that the stinky verses are stalled in the 7th century and that they should not be applicable for future times. On the contrary, the Quran clearly says, "This is the Book; in it is guidance sure, without doubt, to those who fear Allah" (Q 2.02)

Sure enough, we have many lunatics in this world who have received clear guidance from the Quran and they will continue seeking guidance unless the book is chucked into a black hole of an unknown galaxy.

Hit Counter